All people of discerning tastes are welcome to explore the Major's hole, peruse the posts, comment on them and even submit their own billets doux to the Major's repository of antiques, curios and assorted bibelots. There is only one subject not welcome here - politics.

Tuesday, 24 January 2023

The Beatles in bed

When it comes to power pop, few acts can hold a candle to the now sadly defunct Jellyfish.  


If you haven't heard their "Bellybutton" and "Spilt Milk" albums, you've missed out on a real treat.

I have to admit a marginal preference for "Milk", even though the hugely talented Jason Falkner had left the band before it was recorded. It's a stunning album - punchy and melodic, although its predecessor is only a very short step behind.

The whole torrid Jellyfish saga is one worth investigating - but not here, and not now because there are other (jelly) fish to fry...

Since he went solo, Falkner has made some great solo albums that have gone essentially nowhere, although he is, as Jellyfish were, 日本で大成功 (TM) and he still has a very loyal following. He's also regularly in demand as a session player and has recorded with Noel Gallagher, Beck, Paul McCartney, Cheap Trick, Dwight Yoakam, Primal Scream, and many others.


As well as the many original tracks he's recorded, he's always been fond of a cover version or two in the overall mix (from Tom Waits through Be Bop Deluxe to Def Leppard), and amongst his back catalogue are a couple of Beatles covers albums, However, they're not yer usual hack jobs, they're instrumental lullaby-style Beatles songs - "Bedtime with the Beatles - Volumes 1 &2".



Simply but well played with acoustic and electric guitars, keyboards, wordless vocals (apart from the words "Hey Jude" in 'Hey Jude'), an occasional string section and extremely minimal percussion (often none at all), the project sounds a whole lot better to listen to than it might seem on paper. Even though the arrangements are stripped right down and almost totally lacking vocals, Falkner's managed to keep not just the melodies, but also the richness of the harmonic interplay found in the originals, despite the simplicity of the instrumentation and the sparse arrangements. It's also worth noting that many of the songs are slowed down slightly, compared to the originals, but this isn't a distraction.

The choice of the songs favours the softer side of the Beatles - these are, after all, lullabies - but the albums achieve an overall naive charm and grace that is hard to resist. Above all, Falkner treats the Lennon and McCartney compositions with respect and allows the music to retain the essential qualities which first attracted people to it.

Adult listeners may find much to enjoy here.

Or not...see what you think.

43 comments:

  1. To get your copies of Jason's swell Beatles albums, just answer either one or both of these dead easy questions:

    What's one of your all-time absolute favourite cover versions?
    and/or
    What's one of your least favourite cover versions?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Don't Let Me Down" by Phoebe Snow

      Delete
    2. 'Superstar (Groupie)' by Sonic Youth (Carpenters/Delaney & Bonnie)

      Delete
  2. With a Little Help From, My Friends, by Joe Cocker

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yeah, great stuff. How about Junior Parker, Taxman youtube below:

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byjPd28KegM

      Delete
    2. I also prefer Cocker's version of "Watching the River Flow" to Dylan's...good stuff...although Cocker is also responsible for one of the great misreadings of a song: "You Can Leave Your Head On" probably wasn't intended as a striptease number. Granted, that's mostly on "9 1/2 Weeks", but the way he sings it, does make it easy to go with that idea

      Delete
  3. I'm intrigued by your post as I'd never heard of it before. It reminds me a bit of Devo's EZ listening muzak! And that brings me to one of my favorite covers: Devo - Satisfaction, + great versions of that track by Junior Wells and Cat Power. I probably forgot a few 100 other covers I like a lot...

    ReplyDelete
  4. The best cover ever: "Four Strong Winds" by Neil Young. The worst ever would be Hans Hass Jr's take on "American Pie". Wimp

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the worst cover of the worst song achieves something mathematically, i think, but i'm not sure what.

      Delete
    2. You could plot it in the upper right corner of a coordinate plane, with the X axis labeled "worst song" and the Y axis labeled "worst cover"

      Delete
  5. Fairport Convention's "cover" of Sandy Denny's Who Knows where the time goes. Not often thought of as a cover version but Richard Thompson adds so much compared to the "original" as performed with The Strawbs.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Both Fairport and RT have a good eye for a cover song.
      Here's RT with French, Frith, Kaiser and Thompson giving the Beach Boys a good seeing to.
      RT's backing vocals are so English!

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XmWToCWybs

      Delete
  6. One of my top favourites - "Someday Soon" by Judy Collins. I really can't fault it in any way. Emmons on steel, James Burton on guitar, Judy singing like an angel, great song...it might just be the best thing that could ever be labeled "country".

    ReplyDelete
  7. Can't help it, I'm a fan of "When Pigs Fly" you know, covers by bands you wouldn't think would do 'that' song. Although I do love Ooh, Child by the Posies, which makes perfect sense

    ReplyDelete
  8. The blog Música Obscura is dead but the links survive, and two of them might interest Jellyfish fans: Beatnik Beach (Roger Manning and Andy Sturmer's band before Jellyfish) and Umajets (Tim Smith's band after Jellyfish).

    I used to see Tim Smith and Rob Aldridge play in Atlanta as an acoustic duo called Thing 1 Thing 2 before they changed their name to Umajets.

    http://obscure-music.blogspot.com/2014/01/umajets-demolotion-1997_6.html

    http://obscure-music.blogspot.com/2014/01/beatnik-beatch-beatnik-beatch-1988.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I remember plundering that site and others for Jellyfish-related music.
      Sturmer, in particular, seems to have dropped out of recording completely, although he seems to be doing well writing music for Disney and others.

      Delete
  9. Worst cover...any version of Dylan's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door". The original sucked and the many covers haven't shown the song to have any redeeming features.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed, heaven help the fool who covers that one. I don't hate the original, but I once sat through a concert video of Guns N'Roses (curious to see the spectacle of it more than anything), and their version was atrocious. Especially because Axl added his "ay, ay, ay-ay-ay" after every single refrain.

      Delete
    2. That seems harsh.

      One problem is that everyone and their mother have covered it and, considering the simplicity of the song, there is not much of interest you can do with it.

      I can't think of any particularly great versions of that song, But there are some pretty good ones. Roger McGuinn did one on is maligned "& Band" album that is better that is not too shabby.

      Guns'n'Roses' one is definitely terrible, and then they doubled down on their idea by also massacring "Live And Let Die". Everytime I hear Axl Rose's voice, which is both whiny and abrasive and altogether annoying most of the time, and wonder how millions of people were into such an acquired taste of vocalist at the time. I mean,sure, the music did most of the heavy lifting (a little like early Metallica, where Hatfield's weedy, wimpy vocals are more of a background feature, though he got much better as a singer, unlike Axl...), but still, I'm amazed millions and millions wanted to hear that banshee shrieking...

      Delete
  10. The covers you rate/don't rate don't have to be Beatles songs.

    ReplyDelete
  11. (current) favorite cover: Alejandro Escovedo's version of Rolling Stones' "Sway"

    --Muzak McMusics

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He's someone I need to hear more of. Thank you, Mr McM.

      Delete
    2. Everyone does. Got lots of his live stuff, including a set of Al singing covers. I shall convert and post if there is a wish for it. --Muzak McMusics

      Delete
    3. Yes please. That would be splendid!

      Delete
    4. OK, give me a day (or so) and I will post a nice collection of Al singin' the hits. --Muzak McMusics

      Delete
    5. I've been listening to AE a lot today. Wow, how did I miss this guy???
      That ascending steel guitar in "Guilty" - goose bump time!

      Delete
    6. Whoops, two threads gone by, have to check in more regularly...

      Escovedo has some fantastic cover versions. His version of "I Wish I Was Your Mother" is great, and his version of "Evening Gown" qualifies for your first category - it is largely superior to Mick Jagger's original in every way. Oh, and I second "Sway".

      Delete
    7. I have another comp of covers, but I have to find it. In the meantime, not sure where I picked this one up, but it'll do. Al is a national treasure. There isn't a day that I don't listen to him. Enjoy, won't you?

      https://www22.zippyshare.com/v/thQRMnK3/file.html

      -Muzak McMusics

      Delete
  12. So many to choose from...
    Favorite
    Nina Simone's cover of "Screamin'" Jay Hawkins' 'I Put a Spell on You'

    Least favorite:
    Tough one, once again, so many to choose from. Need to think about this for a while

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed great job on this one .

      Delete
    2. Yes, Nina managed to make her version more insidious and dark than Jay's original.

      Delete
    3. She also does a sublime version of Randy Newman's 'I Think It's Going to Rain Today'

      Delete
  13. In the punk scene, it seemed that every band had an irreverent or ironic cover song, chosen to mock the sentiment of the original. Others just cranked up the volume and tempo, leaving the original almost unrecognizable. I mention this as a preface to Husker Du's astonishing take on "Eight Miles High". It was done neither to praise the Byrds, nor to bury them. It is transformative. At its climax, Bob Mould abandons the lyrics to howl in wordless rage. It's a Bad Trip, and I mean that as a compliment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, a good cover has to be 'it's own', no point in a facsimile.

      A bit obvious, but Jeff Buckley, Hallelujah and Lilac Wine from Grace album.
      Also Robert Wyatt, Shipbuilding (by Elvis Costello) from Nothing Can Stop Us, and this beautiful Chic cover
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s1M9YTv3v7I

      Delete
  14. So many good covers to choose from!: Elvis " Tomorrow is a long time" ( B Dylan) fits some moods perfectly.The band on this is superb.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Jason's Beatles collection:

    https://workupload.com/file/9AxS7W7mknH

    ReplyDelete
  16. Grace Jones is a serial cover version artist of all sorts of great songs.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Elvis Costello wrote Almost Blue with Chet Baker in mind. So far all those that are averse to EC's voice here's CB's superb cover of it.
    www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4PKzz81m5c

    ReplyDelete
  18. Another great cover:
    Jason & the Scorchers - "Absolutely Sweet Marie" (Dylan)

    ReplyDelete
  19. It's probably fair to say that the Byrds' "Mr. Tambourine Man" was one of the first great cover versions...

    ReplyDelete
  20. Great cover, Beatles subdivision: Dillard & Clark's take on "Don't Let Me Down"

    ReplyDelete
  21. Since this is a Beatles post, I really like Ian Gomm's cover of You can't do that! Something else though, a few days ago I was in a cool bar which had a great sound system and a pretty decent playlist. One of the covers played was Donna Summer's I Feel Love as a rocking instrumental, unfortunately no idea about who did that? Anyone here?? I Feel Love has been covered countless times...

    ReplyDelete

Mike Bloomfield - east meets west

For a time back in the mid to late 1960s... ...Mike Bloomfield was as significant a player on the US white blues scene as Clapton was on th...